There’s been a lot of buzz about Sunday’s Battlestar Galactica episode, "Crossroads, part 2." You can catch a summary at Bureau42 when its editors post their review (I tend to agree with their sentiments).
WARNING: SPOILERS, yo.
My only displeasure with the episode comes from its lack of surprise, other than one surprise which I’ll mention later in this post. Everything else was quite predictable. We knew that Gaius would get off the hook somehow. We knew that the strange music that only three people seemed to hear was probably Cylonic.
I really liked Lee’s monologue. I rate it up there with Jack Nicholson’s from A Few Good Men and Keanu Reeves’ from Johnny Mnemonic. I’d love to read a transcription of it and see if—and how—it relates to any modern-day situation. It was powerful and well delivered. Frak, it took up the better part of a segment between commercials, iirc.
I had theories on who the final five Cylons were, too. The music thing made it pretty easy to tell, as did the actions in Crossroads, Part 1 of the characters who heard it. So, now we know the final five: Starbuck, Tigh, Chief Tyrol, Anders, and Tory (President Roslin’s aide).
It was fairly obvious after Crossroads, Part 1 that Starbuck was. The scene in which Anders, Tigh, and Tory are all in the bar during Crossroads, Part 1 gave them away, especially when Roslin chides Tory for slacking the past few days and when Caprica Six freaks out Tigh by telling him things that no one else could have known. I don’t think there was a supporting scene for Anders until Crossroads, Part 2 when Anders and Tory were just about to get it on.
Chief was the surprise—a big surprise…to me, at least. However, it’s not so much the fact that he’s a Cylon that intrigues me, but more the implications of his being a Cylon. This means that his and Cally’s child is half-Cylon, just like Hera. This also means that the Cylons not only understand human females’ gestation, but also the role human males play in it.
Perhaps Tyrol and Boomer were supposed to conceive a Cylon child, but when Boomer was shot, that became impossible because the Cylons didn’t have a way to get Boomer back to Galactica. Also, perhaps Anders and Starbuck were supposed to conceive, too, but Starbuck proved too wild/uncontrollable for Anders to handle. Then, something clicked in Anders and Tory and, suddenly, they were trying to conceive.
Tigh confounds some of this. Admiral Adama has known him for forty years. That means that the Cylons implemented the human aging process in his model. Forty years puts Tigh’s creation date during or shortly after the first Cylon war, which makes sense. Here’s another thought to consider: was Ellen a Cylon, too?
There were some people who were suggested to be Cylons. Balter was the obvious one, but it remains to be seen how he’s tied into it. A friend suggested Dualla, but her sickness in an earlier episode indicated that she was not, or Sharon would have gotten it, too.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Rob Owen talked to producer Ron Moore, who revealed some other tidbits, as well as confirmed my thought that Tigh was inserted into human society as an adult.
The worst part of the episode? Having to wait until 2008 to see more Battlestar